The CEOs of Apple, Amazon, Facebook, and Google, have just been grilled by Congress. Find out the key takeaways from top business school professors
In a historic hearing in Washington DC, Apple CEO Tim Cook, Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos, Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg, and Alphabet (Google's parent company) CEO Sundar Pichai, all faced tough questions from the House Judiciary Committee’s antitrust panel.
The culmination of a year-long investigation into the four tech giants, the hearing set out to investigate the precise extent of these companies’ power, and the extent to which they may have been abusing it.
The main focus was around how all the companies have used their extensive reach to harm their competitors and help themselves.
With technology now competing with finance and consulting as a top destination for MBA graduates, it's crucial for MBAs to be aware of the monumental shifts in the sector that may result from the work of the antitrust panel.
BusinessBecause spoke to several leading business professors, who weigh in on the implications of the hearing.
What did the hearing reveal?
In Amazon’s first ever appearance before congress, Jeff Bezos took a beating over counterfeit sellers.
Betsy Sigman, a distinguished professor at Georgetown University's McDonough School of Business, says that finding counterfeits is a herculean task for a company as big as Amazon, but it’s still crucial to work towards better regulation.
Mark Zuckerberg was grilled over buying out Whatsapp and Instagram, two previous rivals, with the express intent of consolidating Facebook’s dominance.
Tim Cook was interrogated over Apple’s monopoly on the App Store, and resisted giving clear answers over questions on the 30% commission it takes from app developers.
Professor Nicholas Economides, of NYU Stern, says the Apple CEO's apparent lack of awareness over anti-competitive practices was hard to believe, and likely nothing but a PR stunt.
Tough questions were levelled at Sundar Pichai for Google’s ad marketplace, where the company essentially acts as operator of the market, as well as the buyer and the seller, which Professor Vasant Dhar, also of NYU Stern, says risks stifling access and innovation in the digital economy.
Google was also interrogated over its influence on the political sphere, which is particularly important given the upcoming election.
However, Republicans tended to focus their questioning solely on the issue of anti-conservative bias based on their own anecdotal evidence, which somewhat took away from the integrity of their questioning.
Democrats were more neutral overall, with most of their questions concerning how a monopoly over any industry squeezed out small businesses.
What was missing from the hearing?
Amazon has substantial power across a range of sectors beyond retail and delivery. Nicholas was surprised that no one asked questions on Amazon’s Web Services (AWS), which owns 34% of the cloud that allows for our internet connection.
Betsy talks about the absence of Twitter from the hearing, and believes it's likely they refused to appear due to the upcoming election. “At this point in the election cycle, [Twitter CEO] Jack Dorsey probably felt he had little to gain and a lot to lose from the hearing.”
There was also a notable lack of questioning regarding user’s personal data, with far more focus on national loyalty. Google took a particular hit in the hearing for dropping out of a key defence contract out of moral concern, back in 2018.
What might the long term implications be?
A final report on the investigation is due in the next few weeks. Depending on its conclusions, this may lead to new laws around user data, legal action, or even forced breakups of the companies by the US government.
Experts are spilt on what the future may hold for big tech.
Professor Lawrence White, of NYU Stern, predicts that the Department of Justice will likely bring a case against Google for unduly favouring its own services in its advertising and search results.
Lawrence also says the Federal Trading Commission may bring a case against Facebook for the misuse of private data. Though the hearing is a big moment for big tech, he believes it's unlikely to stop the continued usage and popularity of the companies’ products and services.
Betsy agrees, highlighting the influence of the pandemic. “Where would we be during the COVID-19 crisis, if these companies were not providing for consumer needs around the world?"
She also predicts that as a result of this hearing, Google, Apple and Amazon may be the subject of new levels of scrutiny that they have escaped so far. Previously they have dodged this because it’s often Facebook getting criticised.
For Vasant, it’s natural that companies build monopolies and use their unique data in ways that are harmful to capitalism and democracy, unless they are properly regulated, as he thinks congress will likely end up doing. “This time, things will change.”
Lawrence is not so sure. “We’ll be back here in two years,” he says.
BB Insights explores the latest research and trends from the business school classroom, drawing on the expertise of world-leading professors to inspire and inform current and future leaders
Student Reviews
Georgetown: McDonough School of Business
GWU - excellent investment for future
George Washington University is a good respected institution with strong programs in various studies, including project management, international affairs, politics, medicine and etc. The university provides students with good opportunities for internships and networking.
GWU has a diverse student body and a reputation for academic excellence.
Safety on campus
I have had an amazing experience at Georgetown University. The classes are enjoyable, the professors are exceptional, and I feel like I am receiving a worthwhile education. The people and faculty at this institution are extraordinary, and I have discovered my true self while being here. Additionally, I always feel secure on campus, as it is the safest place in town.
Georgetown is on top!
I've been enjoying this school so far. I wouldn't alter it, despite the fact that the school is on a hill and that it requires a lot of walking to get around it. For minority and first-generation students, there are a ton of services available. Even though the usual dorm rooms are modest, there is still plenty of area for storage. We have a ton of alternatives every day in the dining halls since they provide so many different dishes from so many different cultures
Physical and mental health
Georgetown is my second home. The pre-professional counselors are incredibly helpful, and I feel supported and inspired to pursue my aspirations. We are certainly ranked as the top research university in the nation. They place a high priority on the development of the students as well as their physical and mental well-being.
Wonderful university
Georgetown University is wonderful. The school's amazing diversity is one of its greatest strengths. The athletes are extremely committed to their sport, and the campus is amazing. The dorms are excellent! They are comfortable and spacious. If you ever find yourself bored on campus, you can always go off campus; it's fantastic. You'll never get bored dining in the cafeteria because the food is so delicious on campus.
Academics
The university's academics are what really set it apart; the lecturers are kind and motivating. Although it can be challenging to connect with the majority of students because they are so intense and competitive, social life and student life are what you make of them. It is undoubtedly a very difficult four years that are challenging to get through. But in the end, it strengthens you and provides you with a wealth of knowledge and incredible prospects.
Fantastic university
Georgetown university is a Fantastic university. The professors are outstanding, there are lots of ways to participate in campus life, and there are numerous groups and organizations where students can get involved. The campus is lovely and always kept clean, and there are people are willing to assist you 24 hours a day whenever you need help.
Review of Georgetown university
Being at Georgetown university has been one of my best experiences. The Professors are knowledgeable, approachable, and very helpful. You will fall in love with Georgetown because of its daily activities, the vibrant students you will encounter, the food served on campus, and the lush surroundings. The housing and dorms are fantastic. There is no better place than Georgetown University if you’re looking to study, discover new things, make lifelong friends, and have fun!
Academically challenging institution
Georgetown University is certainly an academically challenging institution, however, if you ask for assistance when you need it, the workload can be managed. Students are happy to assist one another, and most Professor want you to succeed. Student life is vibrant, the location is excellent and everyone here is friendly and welcoming.
4 Years as an Expat at Georgetown University
Georgetown University provided an exceptional environment for my academic journey as an expat from Italy. As someone who initially felt apprehensive about moving to a new country, Georgetown quickly alleviated my concerns and made my transition incredibly smooth.
One of the standout features of Georgetown is its diverse and welcoming community, particularly for international students. The campus is teeming with students from various corners of the globe, fostering a rich cultural tapestry that made me feel right at home. The vibrant campus life and numerous extracurricular activities offered ample opportunities to connect with fellow students, ensuring a well-rounded and fulfilling university experience.
Georgetown's unique setting within the heart of Washington, DC, adds another layer to its charm. While the university is situated in the bustling city, the campus in the historic area of Georgetown provides a distinct and almost intimate atmosphere. This blend creates a truly unique feel and contributes to an unforgettable educational experience.
Initially enrolled in the College with a desire to major in Linguistics and minor in Art & Journalism, I appreciated the flexibility and openness of the Georgetown education system. After my freshman year, I discovered my true passion lay in Marketing and International Business. The university's seamless transfer process allowed me to transition to the McDonough Business School, where I found the perfect fit for my academic aspirations.
Georgetown's commitment to helping students explore and find their academic niche is indeed one of its most commendable qualities. The ability to explore various subjects before settling on a major is a testament to the university's dedication to fostering individual growth and success. The journey from Linguistics to Marketing & International Business exemplifies the beauty of a Georgetown education — a dynamic and supportive environment where students can discover and pursue their true passions.
In conclusion, Georgetown University provided not only a top-notch academic education but also a transformative and enriching experience. From the welcoming international community to the unique campus setting and the flexibility to explore diverse academic paths, Georgetown stands out as a beacon of higher education that truly caters to the individual journey of each student.
